FIABILITÉ.AUTO

Practical Guides

FR

Skoda Fabia, Octavia, Superb: What Does the Roadworthiness Test Show?

Published 2 November 2026 · 5 min read

Blue 2020 Skoda Octavia IV estate, seen from the front three-quarter angle, parked on a dealership forecourt.
Photo: Vauxford — CC BY-SA 4.0

Skoda belongs to the Volkswagen Group, as does Seat, and shares its platforms. Yet the Czech brand has an image of its own: sensible, rational, good value for money. Within the same industrial group, do Skodas behave any differently from Volkswagens and Seats at the roadworthiness test? Here’s what the official UTAC-OTC data from France’s roadworthiness test shows.

Skoda against the other brands

Across the 13 Skoda families tracked on this site (141,787 tests represented), the weighted average retest rate is 20.14%. That puts Skoda 21st out of 38 brands, 1.2 points above the national reference rate (18.94%, see the 2025 barometer).

Within the Volkswagen Group, Skoda does better than both its sister brands: Volkswagen is 28th (23.44%) and Seat brings up the rear of all 38 (26.67%).

Brand Retest rate Rank (/38)
Dacia 16.78% 10
Citroën 19.16% 18
Skoda 20.14% 21
Toyota 20.92% 22
Ford 23.17% 27
Volkswagen 23.44% 28
Renault 24.91% 33
Peugeot 25.55% 35
Seat 26.67% 38

Skoda therefore sits mid-table, close to Citroën and Toyota, ahead of most of the big mainstream brands. The full brand ranking is on the rankings page (in French).

The Skodas that stand out

Three recent SUVs rank among the best results in the French fleet, on sufficient test volumes:

Model Retest rate National rank (/530) Tests
Kamiq 5.22% 32 7,678
Karoq 5.51% 34 9,742
Kodiaq I 7.07% 66 8,857

The Octavia IV (10.22%) and the Superb III (11.87%) are also well below the national average, but on fewer than 5,000 tests each: their rates should be read with more caution.

One special case: the Fabia I shows a 1.32% retest rate, the lowest of the 530 families tracked. This figure is unusual for a model of that age, given that its successor, the Fabia II, stands at 32.00%, and the British data points the other way (see below). It is reproduced as published by the source, but we don’t present it as a sign that the Fabia I is the safest Skoda.

The Skodas that do less well

Model Retest rate National rank (/530) Tests
Roomster 40.82% 527 5,726
Fabia II 32.00% 440 23,496
Yeti 27.20% 371 8,511

The Roomster is among the four lowest-ranked families in the French fleet. The Fabia II weighs more heavily on the brand average: together with the Fabia III (21.47%), it accounts for 38% of the Skoda tests recorded. The Octavia II and Octavia III show exactly the same rate (25.18%): the UTAC source appears to group these two generations together, which explains the identical figures.

Skoda, Volkswagen, Seat: the same results?

For a like-for-like comparison, you have to look at models from a similar segment and the same era. Where the match is clear-cut, the three brands’ results are very close:

Segment Skoda Volkswagen Seat
Superminis (previous generation) Fabia II: 32.00% Polo V: 32.03% Ibiza IV: 33.07%
Family hatchbacks (previous generation) Octavia III: 25.18% Golf VII: 24.04% Leon III: 26.76%
Family hatchbacks (current generation) Octavia IV: 10.22% Golf VIII: 10.25% Leon IV: 11.41%
Small SUVs Kamiq: 5.22% T-Cross: 5.15% Arona: 6.84%

Across these four segments, the gap between the three brands never exceeds 3 points, and Skoda is never clearly ahead. The gaps are wider elsewhere, in both directions: the small Citigo (14.51%) does much better than the Volkswagen up! (32.59%), the Superb III (11.87%) better than the Passat VIII (18.83%), and the Karoq (5.51%) better than the Tiguan II (15.70%) and the Ateca (17.37%), even though these SUVs are not strictly the same size. Conversely, the Yeti (27.20%) does worse than the Tiguan I (15.70%) from the same era.

Skoda’s lead over Volkswagen and Seat at brand level therefore isn’t down to a systematic gap, model by model. It largely reflects the make-up of the ranges: the Volkswagen and Seat averages are pushed up by very large volumes of older Polos, Golfs, Ibizas and Leons, which Skoda doesn’t have in the same proportion. The UTAC data doesn’t give the age of the vehicles tested, which makes it impossible to put a figure on this effect.

Manufacturer recalls

RappelConso lists 15 separate notices concerning the Skoda families tracked on this site, published between 2020 and 2026. Counted using the method of our recall ranking by brand (a recall counts once per family it concerns), that makes 65 cumulative recalls, or 50.0 per 10 models. Skoda is 8th in this normalised ranking, between Volkswagen (64.4) and Seat (44.5).

Four of these notices concern the driver’s airbag and affect most families in the range. Two mention a fire risk, on Octavias, Superbs and Kodiaqs. The most affected families are the Octavia III (8 recalls), the Kodiaq I and the Octavia IV (7 each). As with other brands, most notices don’t specify the generation and are attached to every possible generation of a model. A recall doesn’t mean a widespread defect, and it doesn’t show up in the retest rate.

The view from abroad

Skoda families aren’t yet part of our model-by-model correspondence table between countries, so the figures below aren’t compared directly with the French families. Measurement methods also differ from one country to another (see comparing countries).

In the UK (MOT), Skoda fails 24.37% of the time and ranks 6th out of 29 makes, ahead of Seat (25.88%, 8th) and Volkswagen (31.16%, 19th). The British data distinguishes between generations. Most Skodas there are below the average for their age band: Octavia Mk3 (16.90% against 20.54% at 5–8 years), Karoq (9.24% against 14.66% at 3–5 years), Kodiaq (10.75% against 14.66%) and Citigo (20.75% against 29.85% at 8–11 years). The Fabia Mk1, however, is above it (47.82% against 40.80% for 15 years and over), the opposite of its French result. The detail is on the Skoda in the UK page (in French).

In the Netherlands (APK), Skoda shows an average failure rate of 31.8% and ranks 26th out of 84 brands, again ahead of Volkswagen (39.9%, 42nd) and Seat (41.7%, 51st). This data is aggregated across all generations, and the result is inferred from the defects recorded. The Octavia (30.79% against 32.18% at 8–11 years), the Superb, the Karoq and the Kodiaq are slightly below the average for their age band, the Fabia slightly above it (41.11% against 39.72% at 11–15 years). See the Skoda in the Netherlands page (in French).

How much does a used Skoda cost?

Model Reference new price Estimated used price
Fabia III €16,000 ~€8,400 at 5 years, ~€6,120 at 8 years
Karoq / Kodiaq I €27,000 ~€17,500 at 3 years, ~€14,170 at 5 years
Octavia III €35,000 ~€16,530 at 6 years, ~€13,390 at 8 years

This is an indicative estimate, not a valuation: it applies a typical depreciation curve by segment to a reference new price. None of these models has its own new price in our data: the average reference price for their segment is used instead, hence the identical figures for the Karoq and the Kodiaq. To compare the models within your budget, see the budget simulator (in French).

What these figures don’t tell you

The retest rate measures the safety points that are inspected, not overall mechanical reliability: an engine or gearbox failure doesn’t show up unless it affects an inspected point. The UTAC data doesn’t give the age of the vehicles tested either, which limits comparisons between brands whose fleets aren’t the same age. See the methodology (in French).

Our take

At France’s roadworthiness test, Skoda does better than Volkswagen and Seat on average, and the same is true in the UK and the Netherlands. But with comparable models from the same era (Fabia II, Polo V and Ibiza IV; Octavia, Golf and Leon; Kamiq, T-Cross and Arona), the three brands achieve very similar results: in those segments, there’s no clear winner. The gap in averages comes mainly from the make-up of the ranges. Within Skoda, the recent SUVs (Kamiq, Karoq, Kodiaq) are the best performers, while the Fabia II and the Roomster lag clearly behind. When buying used, the generation therefore matters more than the badge. The model-by-model detail, including running costs, is on the Skoda brand page (in French).

Data sources: UTAC-OTC (French roadworthiness test, 2025), RappelConso (data.gouv.fr), DVSA MOT testing data (UK, Open Government Licence v3.0), RDW (Netherlands, CC0 licence). Full methodology on the methodology page (in French).

— Also worth reading