Practical Guides
FRFiat 500, Panda, Punto: What Does the Roadworthiness Test Show?
Published 6 November 2026 · 5 min read

500, Panda, Punto: Fiat is a common sight on the French used-car market, especially among small, cheap city cars. Yet the brand has a mixed reputation for reliability. What do the figures say? Here’s what the official UTAC-OTC data from France’s roadworthiness test shows, model by model, across the 16 Fiat families tracked on this site.
Fiat against the other brands
Across the 16 Fiat families tracked (461,696 tests represented), the weighted average retest rate is 23.45%. That puts Fiat 29th out of 38 brands, 4.5 points above the national reference rate (18.94%, see the 2025 barometer).
| Brand | Retest rate | Rank (/38) |
|---|---|---|
| Dacia | 16.78% | 10 |
| Citroën | 19.16% | 18 |
| Toyota | 20.92% | 22 |
| Alfa Romeo | 21.08% | 23 |
| Fiat | 23.45% | 29 |
| Renault | 24.91% | 33 |
| Peugeot | 25.55% | 35 |
Fiat therefore does less well than Dacia, Citroën and Toyota, but better than Renault and Peugeot (in French). It sits level with Volkswagen (23.44%, 28th). Alfa Romeo, the other Italian brand from the same historical group, does slightly better (21.08% across 6 families). The full ranking is on the rankings page (in French).
The Fiat average depends heavily on a single model: the 500 III alone accounts for 36.6% of Fiat tests. In all, 7 of the 16 families are above the national rate, and they make up 71.9% of the brand’s tests.
The Fiats that stand out
Two high-volume families (more than 20,000 tests) do clearly better than the national rate:
| Model | Retest rate | National rank (/530) | Tests |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tipo II | 6.90% | 62 | 26,719 |
| 500X | 10.94% | 134 | 41,719 |
Two other families are below the national rate, on smaller volumes: the 500L (16.47%, 14,131 tests) and the 500 IV (17.95%, 6,885 tests). The Ducato II van shows 4.27% (20th out of 530) on 19,888 tests.
Several small volumes also show low rates: the Punto I (4.56%, 4,349 tests), the Panda I (5.96%, 5,970 tests), the Fiorino III (9.05%) and the Doblo I (11.39%), each with around 5,000 tests. For the Punto I and Panda I, these rates are far lower than those of the following generation (43.71% and 34.22%), the opposite of the usual trend. With samples this small, we draw no conclusion from them.
The Fiats that do less well
| Model | Retest rate | National rank (/530) | Tests |
|---|---|---|---|
| Punto II | 43.71% | 530 | 17,103 |
| Panda II | 34.22% | 487 | 44,553 |
| Punto III | 34.07% | 484 | 48,582 |
| Panda III | 28.75% | 395 | 41,839 |
| 500 III (500/500C) | 24.06% | 311 | 169,055 |
The Punto II has the highest retest rate of all 530 families tracked on this site. The city cars that built Fiat’s reputation on the used market are all above the national rate: the last two Puntos, the last two Pandas and the 500 III, by far the most-tested Fiat family. The Panda III does better than the Panda II, and the Punto III better than the Punto II, but the gap with the national rate is still 10 to 15 points.
Two low-volume families complete the bottom of the table: the Bravo II (36.73%, 6,540 tests) and the Scudo II van (36.41%, 4,072 tests). To see how these city cars compare with their rivals, see our article on the most reliable city cars.
Manufacturer recalls
RappelConso lists 18 separate notices concerning the Fiat families tracked on this site, published between 2022 and 2026. Counted using the method of our recall ranking by brand (a recall counts once per family it concerns), that makes 23 cumulative recalls across 6 of the 16 families. Fiat is 20th in this ranking in raw terms, far behind Peugeot (392) or Citroën (246), with 14.4 recalls per 10 models tracked.
The families concerned are mainly vans: the Scudo II (8 notices), the Doblo I (5) and the Ducato II (2). They are followed by the 500 III and the 500 IV (3 notices each, the same ones: steering support, drive shafts and, in 2024, a battery nut posing a fire risk) and the Tipo II (2). No recalls are listed for the Pandas or the Puntos. 13 of the 18 notices concern a risk of injury, the others a fire or environmental risk.
None of the 18 notices specifies the generation: they are attached to every possible generation of a model, which is why notices published in 2025 and 2026 appear against the Doblo I. A recall doesn’t mean a widespread defect, and it doesn’t show up in the retest rate.
The view from abroad
Fiat models aren’t part of our correspondence table between countries, so we compare brands, and refer to British generations by their own names without formally matching them to the French families. Measurement methods differ from one country to another (see comparing countries).
In the UK (MOT), Fiat fails 35.63% of the time and ranks 23rd out of 29 makes, ahead of Peugeot (36.17%, 25th), Citroën (38.90%, 26th) and Renault (41.05%, 29th), but behind Toyota (29.30%, 17th) and Dacia (27.89%, 12th). The British data distinguishes between generations and ages. The 2007–2019 500, the most-tested (303,415 tests), fails 33.96% of the time at 8–11 years, against a national average of 29.85%. The 2012–2024 Panda is level with the average (29.70% against 29.85%), the 2003–2011 Panda above it (40.91% against 38.66% at 11–15 years). The three generations of Punto sold between 2005 and 2018 are all above their age band, for example the Grande Punto at 48.22% against 40.80% for 15 years and over. The 500X and the Tipo, the best-placed in France, are also above the average at 5–8 years (23.19% and 28.47% against 20.54%). The detail is on the Fiat in the UK page (in French).
In the Netherlands (APK), Fiat shows an average failure rate of 45.6% and ranks 74th out of 84 brands, behind Citroën (43.8%, 65th), Peugeot (42.6%, 59th) and Renault (41.7%, 53rd), against a national rate of around 37.5%. This data is aggregated across all generations, and the result is inferred from the defects recorded. In their main age band, the 500 (42.07% against 39.72% at 11–15 years), the Panda (48.01% against 47.50% at 15 years and over) and the Punto (49.63% against 47.50%) are above the average. See the Fiat in the Netherlands page (in French).
In both countries, most of the commonest Fiats stay above the average for their age band: Fiat’s ranking there isn’t just down to the age of its fleet.
How much does a used Fiat cost?
| Model | Reference new price | Estimated used price |
|---|---|---|
| 500 III | €13,000 | ~€6,490 at 6 years, ~€4,450 at 10 years, ~€2,777 at 15 years |
| Panda III | €16,000 | ~€7,988 at 6 years, ~€5,478 at 10 years |
| Tipo II | €26,000 | ~€16,848 at 3 years, ~€12,282 at 6 years |
This is an indicative estimate, not a valuation: it applies a typical depreciation curve by segment to a reference new price. Only the 500 III has its own new price in our data, itself flagged as uncertain; the Panda III and the Tipo II use their segment’s default price, which is why a Panda III comes out more expensive than a 500 III of the same age. To compare the models within your budget, see the budget simulator (in French) and our guide to which reliable used car to buy by budget.
What these figures don’t tell you
The retest rate measures the safety points that are inspected, not overall mechanical reliability: an engine or gearbox failure doesn’t show up unless it affects an inspected point. The UTAC data doesn’t give the age of the vehicles tested: for France, we can’t say how much of Fiat’s gap comes down to the age of its fleet. Finally, several families rest on fewer than 10,000 tests, which limits fine-grained comparisons. See the methodology (in French).
Our take
At France’s roadworthiness test, Fiat ranks in the bottom third of brands, 4.5 points above the national rate, ahead of Renault and Peugeot but behind Dacia, Citroën and Toyota. That result comes mainly from its most common city cars: the 500 III, Panda II and III, and Punto II and III are all above the national rate, and the Punto II comes last of the 530 families tracked. By contrast, the Tipo II and the 500X do clearly better than average in France, although the British data doesn’t confirm it. In both the UK and the Netherlands, most of the commonest Fiats do worse than the average for their age band. For a buyer on a tight budget, the model and generation matter more than the badge. The model-by-model detail, including running costs, is on the Fiat brand page (in French).
Data sources: UTAC-OTC (French roadworthiness test, 2025), RappelConso (data.gouv.fr), DVSA MOT testing data (UK, Open Government Licence v3.0), RDW (Netherlands, CC0 licence). Full methodology on the methodology page (in French).
— Also worth reading

Practical Guides
Suzuki Swift, Vitara, Ignis: What Does the Roadworthiness Test Show?
What does the official UTAC-OTC data say about Suzukis? Retest rates by model, a comparison with other brands, recalls and the view from abroad.
15 November 2026 · 5 min read

Practical Guides
Nissan Micra, Juke, Qashqai: What Does the Roadworthiness Test Show?
What does the official UTAC-OTC data say about Nissans? Retest rates by model, a comparison with other brands, recalls and the view from abroad.
11 November 2026 · 5 min read

Practical Guides
Citroën C3, C4, Berlingo: What Does the Roadworthiness Test Show?
What does the official UTAC-OTC data say about Citroëns? Retest rates by model, a comparison with other brands, recalls and the view from abroad.
4 November 2026 · 5 min read