FIABILITÉ.AUTO

Practical Guides

FR

Qashqai, 3008 or Tiguan: Which Compact SUV Does Best at the Roadworthiness Test?

Published 27 October 2026 · 7 min read

Blue Peugeot 3008 II seen from the front and above, parked in a car park next to a Citroën C3.
Photo: Charles from Port Chester, New York — CC BY 2.0

The compact SUV has become the most sought-after segment of the French used-car market. The Nissan Qashqai, Peugeot 3008, Volkswagen Tiguan and their rivals often end up on the same shortlist. To compare them on a verifiable measure, here is what the official French roadworthiness test data (UTAC-OTC) shows, generation by generation.

The compact SUV ranking

Eight compact SUV families have enough volume in the data (at least 10,000 inspections per generation), thirteen generations in all. The national retest rate is 18.94%. The average across the 23 saloons and SUVs tracked in our segment rankings is 17%.

Generation Inspections Retest rate National rank (/530) Gap to segment average
Hyundai Tucson IV 14,760 5.16% 28 −11.8 pts
Peugeot 3008 II 194,840 7.02% 64 −10.0 pts
Dacia Duster II 107,256 7.47% 72 −9.5 pts
Nissan Qashqai II 91,734 11.36% 144 −5.6 pts
Hyundai Tucson III 29,850 11.79% 153 −5.2 pts
Volkswagen Tiguan II 67,561 15.70% 196 −1.3 pts
Volkswagen Tiguan I 64,396 15.70% 197 −1.3 pts
Citroën C5 Aircross I 56,290 16.55% 205 −0.5 pts
Toyota C-HR I 47,523 19.83% 253 +2.8 pts
Dacia Duster I 154,734 21.45% 274 +4.5 pts
Peugeot 3008 I 154,517 21.58% 277 +4.6 pts
Renault Kadjar 101,013 26.81% 364 +9.8 pts
Nissan Qashqai I 76,202 28.87% 397 +11.9 pts

One thing stands out straight away: the gap between two generations of the same model is almost always larger than the gap between brands. The 3008 goes from 21.58% (I) to 7.02% (II), the Qashqai from 28.87% to 11.36%, the Duster from 21.45% to 7.47%. Newer generations also have a younger fleet, and age weighs heavily on the retest rate (see from what age does retest risk really increase).

The ones that stand out

The Hyundai Tucson IV has the lowest rate in the selection: 5.16%, 28th out of 530. It is, however, based on the smallest volume in the table (14,760 inspections): it is a recent model whose inspected fleet is still young.

The Peugeot 3008 II (7.02%, 64th) and the Dacia Duster II (7.47%, 72nd) are less than half a point apart. They are also the two most-inspected recent generations in this selection: 194,840 inspections for the 3008 II, 107,256 for the Duster II. Their rates are statistically robust, and there is nothing to separate them.

The Nissan Qashqai II (11.36%, 144th) and the Hyundai Tucson III (11.79%, 153rd) form a second group, again with no significant gap between them, around 7 points below the national rate.

To view them side by side: compare the 3008 II, Duster II and Qashqai II.

The ones that do less well

The Nissan Qashqai I (28.87%, 397th) and the Renault Kadjar (26.81%, 364th) bring up the rear, well above the national rate (by 8 to 10 points). The Qashqai I is the oldest generation in the selection, which explains much of this level. The Kadjar has less of that excuse: production ended in 2022, and it does worse than the Qashqai II, with which it shares its platform.

The Peugeot 3008 I (21.58%) and the Dacia Duster I (21.45%) are level, slightly above the national rate. The Toyota C-HR I (19.83%, 253rd) sits less than a point above the national rate.

The Volkswagen Tiguan needs a word of explanation: both its generations show exactly the same rate (15.70%). The UTAC source appears to group them, as it does for other models (Sandero II and III, Focus III and IV). This rate therefore combines the recent Tiguan II fleet with the older Tiguan I fleet. It sits at roughly the same level as the Citroën C5 Aircross (16.55%), just below the segment average.

Manufacturer recalls

Number of distinct recalls listed by RappelConso for each family, all generations combined:

Family Recalls listed Shared with other models
Peugeot 3008 32 24
Citroën C5 Aircross 16 8
Volkswagen Tiguan 12 5
Dacia Duster 6 2
Hyundai Tucson 3 —
Nissan Qashqai 2 —
Renault Kadjar 1 —
Toyota C-HR 1 —

RappelConso notices often name the model without specifying the generation. Only 7 recalls explicitly target the 3008 II, and 1 the Duster II. The 25 recalls attached to the 3008 I all appear among the 3008 II’s 32. A large share of the 3008’s recalls also cover other Peugeot models (5008, 508, 308, 2008…), because they concern shared engines or components.

A recall flags a defect that the manufacturer fixes free of charge, not an observed breakdown: it should not be read as a reliability indicator. The brand-by-brand context is covered in our recall ranking.

The view from abroad

The British roadworthiness test (MOT) publishes its results by generation and by age band, which makes it possible to compare these models at the same age. We only include the three families whose match with the French generations is established with a high level of confidence. MOT failure rate by vehicle age:

Age UK national average Qashqai 3008 Tiguan
3 to 5 years 14.66% II: 12.73% II: 14.18% II: 11.32%
5 to 8 years 20.54% II: 19.29% II: 22.74% II: 13.65% · I: 17.63%
8 to 11 years 29.85% II: 27.49% · I: 41.86% I: 40.07% I: 23.68%

Every cell is based on more than 11,000 tests. At the same age, the Tiguan fails least often of the three in the UK, for both its generations. Its middling French result is therefore probably down to the grouping of its two generations described above. The 3008 II, very well placed in France, sits at the British average between 3 and 5 years old and slightly above it between 5 and 8.

Gaps like these between countries are common: the two tests do not check the same items, with different thresholds and different patterns of car use (see can we really compare roadworthiness test rates across countries). The British result does not replace the French one. In the Netherlands, the RDW does not distinguish between generations and the APK result is inferred from the defects recorded, so we do not use it for this comparison.

How much does a used compact SUV cost?

Reference new price (mid-range) and used-price estimate by age, from our depreciation model. This is an indicative estimate, not a valuation: condition, actual mileage, engine and trim level move prices well beyond these figures.

Generation Reference new price (range) Estimate at 6 years Estimate at 10 years
Tucson IV €34,100 (€29,900 to €43,900) €16,109 €10,569
Tiguan II €32,150 (€25,975 to €44,470) €15,187 €9,964
C5 Aircross I €31,550 (€24,700 to €39,150) €14,904 €9,778
3008 II €30,000 (€25,900 to €32,450) €14,172 €9,298
Kadjar €28,600 (€22,990 to €33,800) €13,510 €8,864
Tucson III €27,000 (€22,750 to €40,000) €12,755 €8,368
Qashqai II €25,000 (€21,490 to €33,000) €11,810 €7,748
Duster II €15,550 (€11,990 to €20,650) €7,346 €4,820
Duster I €13,900 (€11,900 to €14,900) €6,566 €4,308

We do not give an estimate for the Qashqai I, 3008 I, Tiguan I or C-HR I: we have no new price specific to these generations, and a segment figure would be misleading. To compare the models within your budget, with their estimated running costs, see the budget simulator.

What these figures do not tell you

The retest rate measures the safety items that are inspected (brakes, suspension and steering, lighting, emissions), not overall mechanical reliability: the engine, gearbox and clutch are not inspected. It also depends on the age and mileage of the inspected fleet, which differ from one model to another. When two models are separated by a few tenths of a point, as the 3008 II and the Duster II are, there is no winner. See the methodology.

Our reading

Among recent compact SUVs, the 3008 II and the Duster II are level, well ahead of the national rate, on very large volumes. The Tucson IV shows an even lower rate, but on a younger and smaller fleet. The Qashqai II and the Tucson III follow, with no significant gap between them. The Tiguan, middling in France, is the best placed of the three comparable models in the UK at the same age: the data does not allow a single winner to be named.

In practice, the generation matters far more than the brand: a 3008 II is failed around three times less often than a 3008 I, and a Qashqai II two and a half times less often than a Qashqai I. For a used purchase, the individual car’s service history and the report from its last roadworthiness test matter more than the choice between these models. Details of every generation are available on the Peugeot, Nissan, Volkswagen, Hyundai, Dacia, Citroën, Toyota and Renault brand pages, and in the 2025 rankings.

Data sources: UTAC-OTC (French roadworthiness test, 2025), DVSA MOT (United Kingdom, Open Government Licence v3.0), RappelConso (data.gouv.fr). Full methodology on the methodology page.

— Also worth reading